Home / microfluidic reviews / Microfluidics for cell biology / PDMS in biology research: A critical review on PDMS lithography for biological studies
Microfluidic reviews

PDMS in biology research: A critical review on PDMS lithography for biological studies

Introduction to PDMS in Biology research

PDMS in biology research and more precisely PDMS biocompatibility is an important parameter in many fields of nowadays biology research as microfluidics and lab-on-a-chip is of choice to study various aspects of organ on a chip.

From a technological point of view, the ability to make microfluidic devices in a few hours, without the need for clean room equipments, remains very attractive for research teams beginning in microfluidics.

PDMS chip plasma treater elveflow microfabrication
PDMS chip plasma treater elveflow microfabrication

Crosslinked PDMS block

Additionally PDMS shows numerous advantages coming from its intrinsic properties:

  • the PDMS is biocompatible [1].
  • it is cheap.
  • it is transparent (240nm-1100nm).
  • it has low autofluorescence [2].
  • it can be molded with a resolution down to a few nanometers using modified PDMS [3].
  • PDMS replica can be covalently stuck to a glass substrate using simple plasma treatment to form a sealed microfluidic device.

Advantages of PDMS in biology research

PDMS presents many advantages for biological studies. Some of them are summarised below:

  • PDMS deformability enables easy connections of leak-proof fluidic connections, integration of fluidic valves through PDMS microchannels and it is used to detect very low forces like biomechanics interactions from cells [4].
  • This elastomer is also permeable enough to gas [5] to allow gas supplying for on-chip cells culture [6].
  • PDMS, during cross-linking, can be coated with a controlled thickness on a substrate using a simple spincoat. This allows the fabrication of multilayer devices and the integration of micro valves.

PDMS drawbacks for biology

Microfluidic-chip-made-of-PDMS-glass-with-electrodes
Microfluidic-chip-made-of-PDMS-glass-with-electrodes

Using PDMS in biology research also has some drawbacks:

  •  It is difficult to integrate electrodes or to carry out deposition directly on its surface.
  • One the main drawbacks for cell biology is that PDMS can absorb small hydrophobic molecules like biomolecules and drugs from the solution. Also, many researchers noticed adsorption of proteins on the PDMS surface which has been identified as a major problem for molecular biology. For experiments on cell signaling and determination of drug dose response, the use of PDMS can strongly bias the final result. To overcome this problem, numbers of PDMS surface treatments have been developed depending on the application.
  • Reciprocally, incomplete reticulated PDMS is suspected to migrate within the channel [7]. For that matter, this polymer has been used as an extraction matrix to remove traces of organic compounds from solutions.
  • Another problem met during cell biology experiment in PDMS devices is the permeability of PDMS to water vapor leading to the evaporation of the water contained in the channel as time goes by. This effect can lead to complete device drying or changes in medium osmolarity. It is generally possible to overcome this problem using hydratation channel networks, medium renewal systems or hygrometry controlled environments. Ideally, PDMS devices should be conditioned several hours before use to stabilize the device’s hygrometry.
  • PDMS is sensitive to exposure at some chemicals (see below).
  • PDMS is a material that ages, therefore after a few years the mechanical properties of this material may change.

Despite those limitations, PDMS microfluidic devices are widely used for cell studies and will probably be used more and more for researches in cell biology.

It is then necessary to understand the effects of microscale environment to integrate the results obtained in microfluidic devices with biological experiments obtained using traditional methods.

Biological results obtained in microfluidic devices have already been of great interest for cell biology but the careful understanding of condition changes generated by miniaturization and properties of PDMS will lead to a better understanding of those results.

There are significant differences in proliferation, glucose consumption, gene expression patterns and mitosis defects between traditional well plates and PDMS micro cell culture. Paguirigan & al used In-Cell western (ICW), which allows to quantify protein expression changes, to show differences signaling pathway activation and protein expression levels between experiments in PDMS microsystems and traditional in-vitro experiments [7]. These studies also show significant inhibition of mouse fibroblast proliferation with 3 times higher glucose consumption. Observations in PDMS microchannel show smaller amounts of cells performing division and show several different cell cycle progression problems with a lot of arrest in S/G2 phase.

Possible causes of cell behavior

Microfluidic cell culture perfusion

One explanation of this difference in behavior could be that microscale culture generally increases the cell volume density (cell by unit of medium) compared to multiwall plates leading to more rapid waste products accumulation and medium consumption. But using higher concentration media has little impact on proliferation; suggesting that the volume density is not the predominating factor [7].

Main reasons for these differences between macro and micro scaled culture systems could be:

Uncrosslinked low molecular weight polymer may also leach from the polymer to the medium and monomer could interact with hydrophobic parts of the cell membrane.
Absorption of media components into PDMS, particularly hydrophobic molecules. Hydrophobic growth factors or lipids from the cell culture medium can migrate into the PDMS bulk. This loss of lipids, which is a source of energy for cells, in PDMS may explain the increase in glucose consumption.

One solution to overcome those problems is to perform cell culture with a proper renewal of cell medium which allows evacuation of wastes and renewal of nutriments.

Indeed, Leclerc & al showed that, in the case no media change, glucose and albumin concentrations within the device drop after three days, leading to cells death; but a renewal of media leads to constant albumin and glucose concentrations and long term cells viability [6].

Most of the microfluidic cell culture systems presented before included convective or diffusive medium renewal, depending on the application. Nevertheless, this method may thus not be sufficient for studies like cell signaling studies and determination of drug dose-response where precise molecules amounts absorbed or produced by the cell are crucial. In those cases, medium non-renewal and PDMS absorption could strongly bias the results.

Concerning medium gas composition, since PDMS is permeable to gas, this material allows enough O2 renewal by diffusion through a PDMS wall for cell culture.

Leclerc & al showed that gas diffusion through PDMS walls of 200 µm is sufficient for long term culture of hepatocarcinoma [6]. However, many publications cited before in this review described cell proliferation and growth for weeks. All of them used a medium renewal system to allow proper cells growth for long term experiments.

Conclusions

This review has shown that PDMS in biology research and more precisely PDMS biocompatibility is of importance in many fields of nowadays biology research as microfluidics and lab-on-a-chip is of choice to study the effect of various parameters such as flow rate, and the resulting shear stress on cell growth or bacteria proliferation in a microchannel.

PDMS biocompatibility has been proven over the years. Nevertheless, it remains very dependent upon its environment (time, humidity, temperature) which can be detrimental for experimental reproducibility. It is possible to perform relevant biological studies in PDMS microsystems when taking into account limitations of this technology. Additional studies will be required to identify which kind of results obtained in such kind of microsystems will be exploitable and in which conditions. Instead of trying to correct intrinsic characteristics of PDMS like its surface chemistry, some laboratories develop and test new polymers which could allow same technological potentialities than PDMS with better chemical properties. For more detailed critical information on PDMS as a material for microfluidic devices, one can read [8].

For more reviews about microfluidics, please visit our other reviews here: «Microfluidics reviews». The photos in this article come from the Elveflow® data bank, Wikipedia or elsewhere if specified. Article written by Guilhem Velvé Casquillas and Timothée Houssin and revised by Lauren Durieux.

  1. Belanger, M. C.; Marois, Y. J Biomed Mater Res (2001), 58, 467-77.
  2. Piruska, A.; Nikcevic, I.; Lee, S. H.; Ahn, C.; Heineman, W. R.; Limbach, P. A.; Seliskar, C. J. Lab Chip (2005), 5, 1348-54.
  3. Hua,F.; Sun,Y.; Gaur,A.;Meitl,M. A.; Bilhaut, L.; Rotkina, L.; Wang, J.; Geil, P.; Shim, M.; Rogers, J.A. Nano letters (2004), 4, 2467-2472.
  4. du Roure, O.; Saez, A.; Buguin, A.; Austin, R. H.; Chavrier, P.; Silberzan, P.; Ladoux, B. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA (2005), 102, 2390-5.
  5. Charati, S. G.; Stern, S. A. Macromolecules (1998), 31, 5529-5535.
  6. Leclerc, E.; Sakai, Y.; Fujii, T. Biomedical Microdevices (2003), 5, 109-114.
  7. Paguirigan, A. L.; Beebe, D. J. Integrative Biology (2009), 1, 182-195.
  8. Mukhopadhyay, R. Analytical Chemistry (2007), 79, 3248-3253.
More about microfluidics
Check our premium instruments range
Get the latest microfluidics news


    I hereby agree than Elveflow uses my personal data

    Contact
    How can we help you?
    Quoteor technical request Job application Job
    application
    Collaboration or partnerships Collaborations
    or partnerships
    Customer support Customer
    support
    Others questions Other

      Get a quote




      We will answer within 24 hours

      By filling in your info you accept that we use your data.

      Contacting for
      a job application?
      We are happy that you are interested in Elveflow. You can apply to our open jobs or send us your open application on WelcomeToTheJungle. Over here!

        Collaborations




        We will answer within 24 hours

        By filling in your info you accept that we use your data.

          Need customer support?







          I hereby agree that Elveflow uses my personal data

          We will answer within 24 hours

            How can we help you?




            We will answer within 24 hours

            By filling in your info you accept that we use your data.