Microfluidic magnetic particle sorting and separation : a short review
Magnetic flux sources
Three types of magnetic flux sources are commonly used for micro- and nano-object handling: electromagnets, soft magnets and permanent magnets. Both electromagnets and soft magnets present the advantage of allowing on/off switching, although they usually require cumbersome side-equipment to perform this task. Electromagnets also have the disadvantage of Joule heating, which can be a major inconvenient for microfluidics. Permanent magnets on the other hand cannot be turned off. In some cases this is a great advantage, especially if they are down-scaled and integrated to microsystems, which then are autonomous.
Need advice to do microfluidic magnetic particle separation ?
Feel free to contact us at:
Ask me your question
(We will answer within 24 hours)
Commercial magnetic particle separation
One of the earliest works in magnetic capturing using bulk magnets was reported by Miltenyi in . In this work, a Magnetic Cell Sorter (MACS) from Miltenyi Biotec is used to separate cells labeled with magnetic particles from non-labeled cells. Three basic steps can be observed: the objects of interest are labeled with magnetic particles; the solution passes through the MACS Column, in which the labeled cells are captured by the magnets while the others are collected on the outlet of the column; the captured cells are removed from the action range of the magnetic field and collected.
Magnetic particle sorting with microfluidics
The popularity of magnetism to control particles and samples has increased these last few years. Two of its main advantages are contactless actuation and the possibility to actuate in attraction and/or repulsion. Micro- and nano-particle fabrication is also boosting the use of magnetophoretic methods. Precisely controlled magnetic particles can be produced and functionalized with specific proteins, antibodies or surfactant compounds, for instance. Thus, they can be rendered stable in a certain medium and, more importantly, reactive to very specific target objects. More recently, microfluidics has appeared as a very interesting technology for this field. Its numerous advantages even made it classified as “almost too good to be true” .
This review presents a few examples of applications where magnetic flux sources, magnetic particles and microfluidics are combined in order to perform particle sorting and handling.
Other interesting review is reference .
Magnetic microfluidic particle sorting using bulk magnets
The same principle was used by Hoshino et al. to develop microfluidic systems in which bulk magnets with antiparallel magnetization are disposed side by side in order to create a higher field gradient. This system is used to capture magnetically labeled cancer cells and to observe them inside the microfluidic channel.
Other research groups worked on similar ideas for blocking and unblocking particles. Bulk permanent magnets have also been used, for instance, to give magnetically labeled cells a specific spatial arrangement and to create hair-like structures of magnetic particles .
Soft magnets for microfluidic particle sorting
A schematic of the attraction of magnetic objects above soft magnetic elements is shown by Tseng et al. in . A macroscopic source of magnetic field polarizes micro- or nanoscaled soft magnetic elements, which generate both fields and field gradients that attract the round magnetically labelled objects. These elements have been widely used to capture magnetic particles, to concentrate them into determined locations and separate them from mixed solutions [9-11].
Guo et al. have shown in  the standard steps used to capture and release magnetic particles. The four frames in the picture present sequentially: polarized square patterns produced on a soft magnetic material, with a microfluidic channel above them; magnetic microparticles captured by the magnetic elements; the polarizing field is removed and the captured particles start to unpin; the system no longer holds magnetic particles. Separation by magnetic/non-magnetic character can be done using this technique, which is basically the one shown previously with bulk magnets (i.e. MACS) but integrated in a microfluidic device.
Soft magnets for microfluidic particle positioning
The capturing/releasing approach has been also used for biological studies . Ino et al., for instance, developed a method of organizing magnetically labelled cells based on microstructured pillars produced on soft iron . In certain conditions, a single cell can be trapped above each pillar and individually studied.
Electromagnets for microfluidic particle positioning
Ramadan et al. presented different arrangements of micro-wires which can be integrated in micro-devices, especially for biological manipulation [15, 16]. The figure shows some configurations developed by the group and the resulting particle capture.
Permanent magnets for microfluidic particle positioning
Few works have been reported concerning permanent micro-magnets and microfluidics. Yellen et al. have reported the possibility of positioning non-magnetic particles above arrayed magnetic patterns with high precision . Non-magnetic, fluorescent particles were arrayed in precise positions due to the action of magnetic fields created by both the micro-magnets and an external electromagnet on magnetic nanoparticles dispersed in the solution. In another work, the displacement of a magnetic particle above a similar magnetic pattern was reported, when varying the external applied field .
Permanent magnets for microfluidic particle sorting
Issadore et al. used micrometre-sized NdFeB grains to create high magnetic field gradients close to a microfluidic channel . The NdFeB grains are suspended in uncured PDMS and self-assembled in the presence of an external field. The PDMS is then cured and a microfluidic channel is built above the magnet array. The system was used to sort magnetic/non-magnetic particles and labelled/non-labelled cells with high purity.
Autonomous micromagnets for microfluidic particle sorting
Zanini et al. presented a device incorporating magnetically microstructured hard magnetic NdFeB films. A flat film was microstructured using thermomagnetic patterning, thus producing micromagnets with size in the range of 5 to 100 µm. Magnetic micro and nanoparticles were flown through microfluidic channels produced above the magnets. Capture occured at specific zones above the magnets and release was obtained by increasing the flow rate in the channel. Sorting by magnetic character using magnetic and non-magnetic particles was obtained with high efficiency, up to 99.9% of purity.
Continuous flow microfluidic magnetic sorting
Particle capture and release can be performed with relative ease. Continuously guiding and, in particular, sorting particles with microfluidics, on the other hand, can be a much more difficult task. A good control of the attraction force, as well as a fine balance between magnetic and drag forces are required. Numerous successful attempts of continuous flow magnetic cell sorting have been reported using bulk permanent magnets, soft magnets and electromagnets, as shown below.
Bulk magnets for continuous microfluidic particle sorting
The group of Pamme designed a system combining microfluidics and a bulk permanent magnet, in which the goal is to guide objects towards different outlets according to the magnetic label. One channel inlet is used to pump in the liquid solution containing the objects of study while a buffer solution is pumped in the other inlets. It should be noticed that the position of the magnet is in the opposite side of the main inlet. The outlets are used to collect the solution containing the particles which are separated by labels. This system has been used to sort magnetic particles based on their susceptibilities ; cells labeled with magnetic particles based on magnetic moment and particle size ; magnetic particles based on the variation of magnetic response in temperature ; and different types of cells, based on their endocytotic capacity .
Soft magnetic elements for continuous microfluidic particle sorting
A system based on soft magnets for particle sorting was developed by Afshar et al. (Prof. Martin Gijs’ group). The system is composed of soft magnetic poles near a microfluidic channel, the magnetic element being polarized by a coil. Two distinct zones of magnetic actuation are present. The first zone has the same function of attracting and concentrating the magnetic particles which flow near the magnetized elements. The second active zone is situated further in the channel and attracts the particles to the other side of the channel. The attraction force acting on the particles depends on their dimension, thus, particles of different size can be separated, as shown in the second frame of the figure .
Han et al. used a ferromagnetic wire magnetized by an external field in order to separate red and white blood cells [26,27]. Since red blood cells (RBC) are attracted to the highest magnetic field gradients, while white blood cells (WBC) are repelled from it, these cells can be sorted using a simple device. In the figure, the solution containing both types of cells is pumped in the only inlet and exits the channel by three possible outlets. The ferromagnetic wire placed in the center of the channel concentrates the RBC, which are guided towards the central outlet, while the WBC are repelled from the wire and exit the channel by the two external outlets.
Still based on the continuous sorting of objects, many advances have been made using ferromagnetic stripes. A magnetically tagged object submitted to a drag force inside a microfluidic channel is also submitted to a magnetic force when passing near soft magnetic stripes. The angle between the magnetic and the drag force deviates the object from its initial path, thus, separation can be achieved. This binary separation (magnetic/non-magnetic) has been reported in several publications [28,29].
Other systems based on the deviation of particles for separation were reported by Derec et al.  and Shevkoplyas et al. . The deviation of the particles, in this case, is obtained by a permanent magnetic field created by a wire in the vicinities of the microfluidic channel. In the system produced by the group of Shevkoplyas a microfluidic channel is seen in the center, with a conductive wires on each side. The magnetic particles inside the channel are randomly dispersed at first, since no magnetic field acts on them. Once a current passes through the top wire, the particles are attracted to it and are concentrated on one side of the channel. This method can be used to sort particles in a continuous fashion, since they are continuously guided, instead of captured/released.
Soft magnetic elements for continuous multiple microfluidic particle sorting
Adams et al. developed a system based on the same principle, but in which three types of objects can be sorted . The system has one inlet for the solution of objects to be sorted and one inlet for a buffer solution. The objects are concentrated in one side of the channel. A first set of magnetic stripes deviates a first group of magnetically labelled objects, while a second set deviates a second group. The third group is not labelled and follows the fluid flow without being deviated. The three groups are collected in different conveniently placed outlets. The separation of two different magnetically labelled objects results from a difference in both the drag force and the magnetic force, due to the use of different labels.
Electromagnets for microfluidic particle sorting
Another interesting system was developed by Fulcrand et al. (A.-M. Gué’s group), which allows dynamic particle manipulation. Magnetic particles flow in a liquid solution through a microfluidic channel. A set of micro-coils disposed successively from one side of the channel to the other is placed below the channel. The first coil is activated in order to capture the magnetic beads. The following coil is activated and the precedent is deactivated, displacing the group of particles further in the channel and towards a different position in the channel section. This is repeated until the particles are conveniently placed as regards to the channel outlets, then the particles are released from the coils and collected.
WORLD LEADER IN HIGH PERFORMANCE MICROFLUIDIC FLOW CONTROL
We provide the only microfluidic flow control system using Piezo technology that enables a blazing fast flow change in your microdevice.
For more tutorial about microfluidics, please visit our other tutorials here: «Microfluidics tutorials». The photos in this article come from the Elveflow® data bank, Wikipedia or elsewhere if precised. Article written by Luiz Zanini and Timothée Houssin.
 S. Miltenyi et al., “High gradient magnetic cell separation with macs,” Cytometry, vol. 11, no. 2, pp. 231–238, 1990.
 M. Biotec, “Miltenyi Biotec website, http://www.miltenyibiotec.com,” May 2014.
 G. M. Whitesides, “The origins and the future of microfluidics,” Nature, vol. 442, pp. 368–373, 2006.
 Yuqin S, Bo Y, Qun F. “Application of Magnetic Control Technique in Microfluidic Chips”. Prog Chem. jan 2010;22(1):133‑9
 K. Hoshino et al., “Microchip-based immunomagnetic detection of circulating tumor cells,” Lab Chip, vol. 11, 2011.
 G. R. Souza et al., “Three-dimensional tissue culture based on magnetic cell levitation,” Nature Nanotechnology, vol. 5, pp. 291–296, 2010.
 J. V. I. Timonen et al., “A facile template-free approach to magnetodriven, multifunctional artificial cilia,” ACS Applied Materials and Interfaces, vol. 2, no. 8, pp. 2226–2230, 2010.
 P. Tseng et al., “Rapid and dynamic intracellular patterning of cell-internalized magnetic fluorescent nanoparticles,” Nano Letters, vol. 9, no. 8, pp. 3053–3059, 2009. PMID: 19572731.
 M. Bu et al., “Characterization of a microfluidic magnetic bead separator for high-throughput applications,” Sensors and Actuators A: Physical, vol. 145-146, pp. 430–436, 2008. Special Issue: Transducers 07 Eurosensors XXI, The 14th International Conference on Solid State Sensors, Actuators and Microsystems and the 21st European Conference on Solid-State Transducers.
 A. Sinha et al., “Magnetic separation from superparamagnetic particle suspensions,” Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, vol. 321, no. 14, pp. 2251 – 2256, 2009. Current Perspectives: Modern Microwave Materials.
 Y. Moser et al., “Quadrupolar magnetic actuation of superparamagnetic particles for enhanced microfluidic perfusion,” Applied Physics Letters, vol. 94, no. 2, p. 022505, 2009.
 S. S. Guo et al., “Response of super-paramagnetic beads in microfluidic devices with integrated magnetic micro-columns,” Microelectron. Eng., vol. 83, pp. 1655–1659, April 2006.
 M. Tanase et al., “Assembly of multicellular constructs and microarrays of cells using magnetic nanowires,” Lab Chip, vol. 5, 2005.
 K. Ino et al., “Cell culture arrays using magnetic force-based cell patterning for dynamic single cell analysis,” Lab Chip, vol. 8, 2008.
 Q. Ramadan et al., “On-chip micro-electromagnets for magnetic-based bio-molecules separation,” Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, vol. 281, no. 2-3, pp. 150 – 172, 2004.
 Q. Ramadan et al., “Customized trapping of magnetic particles,” Microfluidics and Nanofluidics, vol. 6, pp. 53–62, 2009.
 B. B. Yellen et al., “Arranging matter by magnetic nanoparticle assemblers,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 102, no. 25, pp. 8860–8864, 2005.
 M. A. Tahir et al., “Transport of superparamagnetic beads through a two-dimensional potential energy landscape,” Phys. Rev. E, vol. 84, p. 011403, Jul 2011.
 D. Issadore et al., “Self-assembled magnetic filter for highly efficient immunomagnetic separation,” Lab Chip, vol. 11, 2011.
 L. F. Zanini et al., “Autonomous micro-magnet based systems for highly efficient magnetic separation,” Applied Physics Letters, vol. 99, no. 23, p. 232504, 2011.
 N. Pamm et al., “On-chip free-flow magnetophoresis: Separation and detection of mixtures of magnetic particles in continuous flow,” Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, vol. 307, no. 2, pp. 237–244, 2006.
 N. Pamme et al., “Continuous sorting of magnetic cells via on-chip free-flow magnetophoresis,” Lab Chip, vol. 6, 2006.
 M. D. Tarn et al., “The importance of particle type selection and temperature control for on-chip free-flow magnetophoresis,” Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials, vol. 321, no. 24, pp. 4115 – 4122, 2009.
 D. Robert et al., “Cell sorting by endocytotic capacity in a microfluidic magnetophoresis device,” Lab Chip, vol. 11, 2011.
 R. Afshar et al., “Magnetic particle dosing and size separation in a microfluidic channel,” in Sensors And Actuators B-Chemical, vol. 154, pp. 73–80, 2011.
 K.-H. Han et al., “Diamagnetic capture mode magnetophoretic microseparator for blood cells,” Journal of Microelectromechanical Systems, vol. 14, no. 6, pp. 1422–1431, 2005.
 K.-H. Han et al., “Continuous magnetophoretic separation of blood cells in microdevice format,” Journal of Applied Physics, vol. 96, no. 10, pp. 5797–5802, 2004.
 D. W. Inglis et al., “Continuous microfluidic immunomagnetic cell separation,” Applied Physics Letters, vol. 85, no. 21, pp. 5093–5095, 2004.
 D. W. Inglis et al., “Microfluidic high gradient magnetic cell separation,” Journal of Applied Physics, vol. 99, no. 8, p. 08K101, 2006.
 C. Derec et al., “Local control of magnetic objects in microfluidic channels,” Microfluidics and Nanofluidics, vol. 8, pp. 123–130, 2010. 10.1007/s10404-009-0486-6.
 S. S. Shevkoplyas et al., “The force acting on a superparamagnetic bead due to an applied magnetic field,” Lab Chip, vol. 7, 2007.
 J. D. Adams et al., “Multitarget magnetic activated cell sorter,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol. 105, no. 47, pp. 18165–18170, 2008.
 R. Fulcrand et al., “On chip magnetic actuator for batch-mode dynamic manipulation of magnetic particles in compact lab-on-chip,” Sensors and Actuators B: Chemical, vol. 160, no. 1, pp. 1520 – 1528, 2011.